No argument based on the ends justifying the means can support that action. Ultimately, the supreme court sided with the commission, finding that Stigler had acted improperly by holding the hearing without one party's attorney and proceeding to "adjudicate custody, visitation, and child support for the pendency of the dissolution action, even though there was no request on file that he do so." The court also stated that Stigler "acted in callous disregard of 's rights by calling him to the stand and, through leading questions, obtaining admissions of domestic abuse. He also claimed that the chairman showed animosity towards him during the hearing by "interrupting an offer of proof" and refusing to allow the judge to make opening and closing statements. He later withdrew that request, but restated it on the morning of the commission hearing. He had also asked for the commission chairman to recuse himself from the hearing. Stigler argued that the commissions hearings should have been held publicly and that he had been unfairly denied access to the written complaints submitted against him by the lawyer in the case. The commission requested that the supreme court reprimand Stigler, while he filed a responses arguing that no discipline was warranted. The commission also argued that his "use of a district court subpoena to obtain documents that were the subject of a pending motion to produce before the commission was an act deliberately calculated to circumvent the commission's authority," and the body further described the judge's behavior towards the commission as "disrespectful." The commission had cited Stigler for holding a hearing in the absence of one party's lawyer, "eliciting admissions of domestic abuse from by questions from the bench," and considering the application for attorney fees from the divorce case after exhibiting "displeasure" with the husband's attorney. The matter went to the high court by request of the Iowa Commission on Judicial Qualifications. On March 22, 2000, the Iowa Supreme Court reprimanded Stigler over his handling of a divorce case hearing in 1998. Īs of September 2, 2016, there was one record of disciplinary orders against Stigler from the Iowa Judicial Branch Office of Professional Regulation. Stigler received 26,332 votes in favor of his retention and 7,106 against it in the general election on November 4, 1986. Stigler won retention to his first full six-year term as a district court judge for Iowa's District 1B in 1986. Stigler received 48,947 votes in favor of his retention and 12,035 against it in the general election on November 3, 1992. Stigler won retention to his second full six-year term as a district court judge for Iowa's District 1B in 1992. Stigler received 39,997 votes in favor of his retention and 8,173 against it in the general election on November 3, 1998. Stigler won retention to his third full six-year term as a district court judge for Iowa's District 1B in 1998. Stigler received 54,435 votes in favor of his retention and 13,907 against it in the general election on November 2, 2004. Stigler won retention to his fourth full six-year term as a district court judge for Iowa's District 1B in 2004. Stigler received 41,562 votes in favor of his retention and 17,833 against it in the general election on November 2, 2010. Stigler won retention to his fifth full six-year term as a district court judge for Iowa's District 1B in 2004. Source: Iowa Secretary of State, "November 8, 2016, General Election: Judicial," accessed November 9, 2016Ģ010 See also: Iowa judicial elections, 2010 Iowa District 1B, District Court Judge George L. Stigler Retention Election with 75.10% of the vote. Stigler was retained in the Iowa District 1B, District Court Judge George L. Elections 2016 See also: Iowa local trial court judicial elections, 2016įifty-nine Iowa District Court judges sought retention in the general election on November 8, 2016. Stigler also served six years on the Black Hawk County Veteran Affairs Commission. During his service, he reached the rank of colonel, served as the senior judge advocate general (JAG) officer for Iowa, and went to Kosovo on a peacekeeping mission from 2003 to 2004. Stigler served in the Iowa National Guard for over 38 years. He was licensed to practice law in Iowa on June 12, 1975, and was hired as an assistant county attorney for Black Hawk County. Stigler earned a bachelor's degree from the University of Northern Iowa and a J.D. Stigler attended Waterloo Community Schools' Hawthorne Elementary and McKinstry Junior High before graduating from Waterloo East High in 1968. His father was a tenant sharecropper before the family moved to Iowa. Stigler was born in Durant, Miss., and moved to Waterloo with his family in 1957.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |